Top 5 Cheesecake Places to Visit in NYC

Eileen’s has been in the cheesecake business since 1975. It has been honored with TV appearances as New York’s Best Cheesecake. This bakery also received the certificate of excellence by TripAdvisor as New York’s #1 Dessert in 2018. Here you’ll find a wide variety of toppings from strawberry to cherry, and a long list of cheesecake flavors such as salted caramel, peanut butter, and chocolate bourbon, among others. Whether you’re craving something dense or fluffy, sweet or tart, Eileen’s has you covered! The cafe is right next door to Little Italy, one of New York’s most picturesque neighborhoods. For cheesecake lovers, Eileen’s is a must! Yummy!

Where: Eileen’s Special Cheesecake; 17 Cleveland Place PI, Lower Manhattan (25 min drive from The Lombardy Hotel).

When: Monday – Friday: 9 am – 9 pm; Saturday – Sunday: 11 am – 8 pm

Veniero’s story starts in 1894 when Italian, Antonio Veniero immigrated to New York, and soon opened his own cafe. Since then, this East Village bakery has offered a variety of pastries, biscotti, and of course, cheesecake. The show-stopping cheesecakes are prepared with fresh ricotta and whole eggs. At this Italian bakery, you can buy fresh cheesecakes at the to-go counter, or order a slice and a cup of coffee from a cozy table. The biggest problem you’ll have at Veniero’s is figuring out what to eat for dessert. How about a slice of cheesecake with chocolate, or a raspberry mousse? The vast selection here will satisfy even the biggest sweet tooth. Veniero’s is a highly recommended after-dinner treat when visiting the East Village!

Where: Veniero’s Pasticceria & Caffe; 342 E 11th St, East Village (20 min drive from The Lombardy Hotel).

When: Sunday – Thursday: 8 am – 12 am; Friday – Saturday: 8 am – 1 am

Junior’s first opened on election day,1950. Owner Harry Rosen and one of his bakers tested and tasted until they found the recipe they still use today. Junior’s is always a great option to try if you are just passing through Times Square, or rounding out a night at the theatre, or best of all, when you’re just in the mood for cheesecake and want to indulge. You can choose from flavors including: original NY plain cheesecake, cherry chocolate cheesecake, strawberry cheesecake, brownie explosion, tiramisu cheesecake, and red velvet cheesecake, among others. You’ll feel comfortable and satiated in the American-style diner atmosphere at Junior’s!

Where: Junior’s; 1626 Broadway, W 49th St, (10 min drive from The Lombardy Hotel).

When: Sunday – Thursday: 6:30 am – 12 am; Friday – Saturday: 6:30 am – 1 am

At this Upper East Side bake shop you’ll find plain New York style, cherry, and pumpkin cheesecake. The fruity toppings on the cheesecakes, cream filling and sweet graham cracker crust are all made entirely in-house. TLRH’s cheesecakes are characterized by their creamy, silky texture, and incredibly balanced taste. You’ll say yum with every bite!

Where: Two Little Red Hens; 1652 2nd Ave, 86th St, YorkVille (10 min drive from The Lombardy Hotel).

When: Monday – Thursday: 7:30 am – 9 pm; Friday: 7:30 – 10 pm; Saturday: 8 am – 10 pm; Sunday: 8 am – 8 pm

Martha’s is a Greek-owned bakery in Queens, with additional locations in Astoria, Forest Hills, and Bayside. Cheesecake options at Martha’s include Mississippi mud, peanut-butter, strawberry, chocolate chip, and New York-style, among others. If you have a sweet tooth, then this place needs to be on your list.

Where: Martha’s Country Bakery; 36-21 Ditmars Blvd. Astoria, (30 min drive – nearest from The Lombardy Hotel).

When: Monday – Thursday: 7:30 am – 9 pm; Friday: 7:30 – 10 pm; Saturday: 8 am – 10 pm; Sunday: 8 am – 8 pm

We delight in hosting everyone, from tourists to the business traveler with our uniquely decorated and impeccably served rooms. Our main goal is to give you a beautiful experience during your stay in New York City. We’ll be delighted to host you whether for business or just for leisure.